Motivation

In multi-threaded applications running on multi-core systems, it occurs often that there are certain data structures, which are frequently read but relatively seldom changed. An example of this would be a database server that has a list of databases that changes rarely, but needs to be consulted for every single query hitting the database. In such situations one needs to guarantee fast read access as well as protection against inconsistencies, use after free and memory leaks.

Therefore we seek a lock-free protection mechanism that scales to lots of threads on modern machines and uses only C++11 standard library methods. The mechanism should be easy to use and easy to understand and prove correct. This article presents a solution to this, which is probably not new, but which we still did not find anywhere else.

The concrete challenge at hand

Assume a global data structure on the heap and a single atomic pointer P to it. If (fast) readers access this completely unprotected, then a (slow) writer can create a completely new data structure and then change the pointer to the new structure with an atomic operation. Since writing is not time critical, one can easily use a mutex to ensure that there is only a single writer at any given time. The only problem is to decide, when it is safe to destruct the old value, because the writer cannot easily know that no reader is still accessing the old values. The challenge is aggravated by the fact that without thread synchronization it is unclear, when a reader actually sees the new pointer value, in particular on a multi-core machine with a complex system of caches.

If you want to see our solution directly, scroll down to “Source code links“. We first present a classical good approach and then try to improve on it. More info